Virtues for Innovation in Practice (VIPs)
A Virtue Ethics Account of Responsibility for Biotechnology
Advances in biotechnology are rapidly expanding possibilities for engineering life, such as through gene editing. These novel applications beget empirical and ethical questions in both the practice of innovation and usage. Modifying organisms comes with uncertainties concerning issues of safety and security, sharing benefits, and naturalness. Biotechnology is changing how we engineer life to our benefit, leading to serious implications for conceptions of the good life for human flourishing. Cultivating virtues for innovation in practice (VIPs) can help us make responsible choices for the good life. This research will take up the task of formulating such a framework. The main research question is: how can empirical ethics provide a virtue ethics account of moral responsibility for uncertainties in biotechnology while building on existing normative frameworks of innovators and users to become part of practices, and what is this account? This project will study biotechnology practices during innovation and usage through a philosophical lens, notably through the work of Alasdair MacIntyre. The focus emerges from an understanding that practices are where choices get made, a communityâ??s norms and values take shape, and moral agents deal with problems and/or uncertainties. Since virtues are practicable and ethicists of technology want those practicing and using biotechnology innovations to act responsibly when faced with uncertainties, a virtue ethics account of responsibility is necessary and helpful. Combining empirical ethnographic research methods with conceptual analyses in the ethics of technology, the project will uncover existing ways of dealing with problems or uncertainties, develop a conceptual framework based on virtue ethics, and yield practical recommendations for policy, research, industry, and education.
Click here for information about the funder and this grant.
Inspiration for this project comes from my own involvement with practitioners in biotechnology and important publications in the field of ethics, cultural anthropology and science and technology studies. These books have helped me situate my experiences into a broader question that has relevance for academic research and practice. They also give an idea of the interdisciplinary research done in this project.
1- Synthetic, how life got made, by Sophia Roosth is the first ethnography of synthetic biologists and their practice of making life. This book provides an in-depth analysis of main ways of thinking about doing synthetic biology.
https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/S/bo25468780.html
2- After Virtue, A Study in Moral Theory, by Alasdair MacIntyre is a contemporary classic of ethical theory. What strikes me as particularly inspiring is the notion of practice that is central to the exercise of the virtues, and how it creates bridges between empirical research and moral theory.
https://undpress.nd.edu/9780268035044/after-virtue/
3- Care in Practice, an edited volume by Annemarie Mol, Ingunn Moser and Jeannette Pols presents a study of many cases where the role of technology in caring practices, on the farm for instance, is problematized, and centred around the human experience rather than technological features.
https://www.transcript-verlag.de/978-3-8376-1447-3/care-in-practice/
4- Technology and the Virtues: A Philosophical Guide to a Future Worth Wanting by Shannon Vallor presents another contemporary approach to virtue ethics stemming from challenges with internet and communication technologies. The premise of Vallor’s investigation are similar to mine in that we recognize the need for a set of virtues that help dealing with the complexity of our world.